A
On a still afternoon in late July, the air above a bare car park can be several degrees warmer than the air beneath a row of mature trees just a few streets away, and at ground level, where the sun strikes the asphalt directly, the gap is wider still. Climatologists call this pattern the urban heat island. Brick, concrete and dark road surfaces absorb solar energy throughout the day and then release it slowly after sunset, so that densely populated districts often fail to cool down overnight. Many doctors regard these warm nights, rather than the daytime peaks, as the most dangerous feature of a heatwave, because the body is denied the chance to recover. For most of the twentieth century, however, city trees were treated as a matter of appearance rather than of public health: something to be added once the serious business of building roads, drains and housing had been completed.
B
Trees lower temperatures in two distinct ways. The first is simple shade: leaves intercept sunlight before it can reach, and heat, the pavements and walls below. The second is less visible. Through a process known as evapotranspiration, a tree draws water up from the soil and releases it as vapour through its leaves, and the energy needed to turn that water into vapour is taken from the surrounding air. Both effects depend far more on the extent of the canopy than on the number of trunks. A single mature plane tree, with a crown spreading twenty metres or more, may provide as much cooling as a dozen young trees along the same street, which is why researchers increasingly measure tree cover as the proportion of ground lying beneath leaves rather than as a simple count.
C
This cover is rarely shared out evenly. Surveys carried out in a number of European and North American cities have found that wealthier neighbourhoods tend to have markedly more canopy than poorer ones, partly because they were often laid out with gardens and wide avenues, and partly because their residents have been better placed to campaign for new planting. The consequences are not merely a matter of looks. In several studies, the most deprived districts recorded the highest surface temperatures during heatwaves, and it is in those same districts that elderly people, those with long-term illnesses and families in poorly insulated flats are most likely to live. For public health officials, where new trees are planted has therefore become as important a question as how many.
D
Trees are not, however, without their drawbacks. Their roots can lift paving stones and crack the pipes that run beneath a street, fallen leaves block drains in autumn, and large branches occasionally come down in storms, leaving councils open to claims for damage. Less widely known is the fact that certain species, including some oaks and poplars, give off natural compounds on hot days which, in strong sunlight, react with traffic fumes to form ozone, a pollutant that irritates the lungs. Others produce large quantities of pollen, a serious concern for the growing number of city dwellers with allergies. None of these problems is a reason to stop planting, but each is a reason to plant with care.
E
Choosing which trees to plant has therefore become a long-term calculation. A sapling put in the ground today will have to survive the summers of the 2070s, which climate models suggest will be considerably hotter and drier than those of the present, so many cities now favour species that can tolerate long periods without rain. Planners have also learnt from history. In the last century, a fungal disease spread by beetles killed millions of elms across Europe and North America, stripping entire avenues bare within a few years, precisely because so many streets had been planted with nothing else. Today, a common rule is that no single species should make up more than a tenth of a city's trees, so that one pest cannot repeat the damage done to a monoculture.
F
A further shift concerns the way trees are justified. Faced with tight budgets, a number of city authorities have begun to calculate a financial value for each tree, adding together the money it saves on air conditioning, the rainwater it absorbs before it can overwhelm the drains and even the estimated savings to the health service. Supporters argue that such figures allow trees to compete for funding on equal terms with roads and buildings, since they speak the language that budget committees understand. The practice nevertheless remains contentious. Critics point out that many of the benefits, from birdsong to a sense of calm, cannot sensibly be expressed in money, and they fear that a tree which scores poorly on paper may become easier to cut down.
G
Perhaps the hardest problem, though, is time. A newly planted tree may take twenty or thirty years to provide meaningful shade, and many do not survive that long: in some cities, a large share of street saplings die within their first five years, often for want of watering during dry spells. A mature tree, by contrast, is already doing its work. For this reason, a growing number of urban ecologists argue that protecting the trees a city already has is often far more cost-effective than planting new ones, and that a sapling, however welcome, should never be presented as a like-for-like replacement for a large tree that has been felled.